Punkie's Online Diary
The Ongoing Saga of Punkie into the 21st Century

[Home Page]
[Go Straight to Blog Archives]
[Technical (Livejournal) Journal]
[Enable Frames]

[ Previous entry: "Flame on!" ] [Main Index] [ Next entry: "... And Wil Wheaton responds!" ]

12/10/2003 Entry: "Children of the December Sorrow"

I have to pause here because VB.NET is just so frustrating. I hate Microsoft products so much, I wouldn't be surprised if it gave me a heart attack one day.

Anyway, it looks like Christine's party is going have guests after all! After the initial sendout, a lot of people either waffled or said they couldn't come, but now that's starting to change. The guest list was 21 invited (expecting 15 to show), and then it was down to 4, but now it's crept back up to about 20. I really hope this goes well! We're going to Hama Sushi, which is a small sushi restaurant nearby that wins awards every year for the area's best sushi. That's no small feat. And it is deserved.

But of course, the underlying frustration is that having a birthday near, or in Christine and our friend Moria's case, ON Christmas ... totally, irrevocably, sucks. I can only say it sucks by proxy because my birthday was only after first quarter's report cards came out a week earlier. This sucked because there was always an air of disappointment in the house that I was not a straight-A student, and so my birthday was a kind of "regretful pardon" like the kind you give to a Mafia don who got off because of a technicality. But that pales in comparison to having a birthday near or on Christmas.

The first thing you notice as a kid is that no one ever remembers. The holiday hustle and bustle robs your chance of celebrating your birth. It's like celebrating it with a more popular twin. It's also bloody hard to get guests because people are always going to holiday parties, or they are out of town with relatives. The closer to Christmas you are born, the more likely your party has to be a week or more away from the actual date. Birthday parties lose magic when they are held off-kilter to the actual day. I mean, if you birthday falls on a Wednesday, and you have the party on a Saturday before or after, that's not so bad. But if you date falls on Dec 24th, and you are forced to hold it the weekend of Dec 3rd, or January 8th ... it feels like you've been cheated. Like you've been bumped from the schedule as unimportant, secondary lodge meeting.

Christine's own mom forgot her daughter's birthday several times. Her own mom, and in the house growing up, there was only the two of them. This is how bad it can get.

The second terrible thing is the gift department. This totally sucks as a kid, when gifts are everything. You have no job, no money, and unless your parents are wealthy and you have an allowance, you really have no way to get anything you want. Thus, you depend on others to get them for you, and already you're at a disadvantage. Most American kids get gifts on three days a year: Christmas, Easter, and their birthday. Easter is usually a small basket of candy, maybe a toy or two, so the other two account for maybe 90% of what you receive. Now, if you are unlucky enough to have your birthday near Christmas, many people give you one gift as "both a Christmas and a birthday present." Usually with a stupid grin. Rarely is the gift worth two. It's like they are taking advantage of your situation and saving a few bucks in the process. As the kids used to say, "What a gyp!" In statistical terms, that's 45% of your income gone. Almost half.

I am not so sure if being Jewish makes it better. Bruce?

So now you feel forgotten and cheated. What could make it worse? Patronization. "You must feel so lucky to celebrate your birthday with the baby Jesus," and "You were a special present for your mom and dad." No. It is not special. You do not understand at all. Let's cancel your birthday, give you a "combo gift" on another unrelated day, and then see how special YOU feel. But you can't say anything because you look bad, ungrateful, and bitter.

So I want to be that voice for them. I want to stand up for those who are tired of losing 45% of what circumstance has taken from them. I want to start a sensitivity campaign for Christine, Moria, Bruce, and those others who may have felt cheated, alone, and depressed on the holiday season due to circumstances beyond their control. I'll call it, "Children of the December Sorrow." You can help!

Make a point to remember the actual birthday. Make a phone call, send an e-mail, do something that only mentions the birthday, on the birthday, and don't mention Christmas at all. Treat Christmas in the conversation like an uncomfortable memory you wouldn't bring up unless they do.

Never give a "combo gift." Get two gifts, or if you can only afford one because of your holiday spending spree, most Children of the December Sorrow would rather get a birthday gift than a Christmas one.

Never, ever mention having a birthday near Christmas as a good thing. If you ask, "When's your birthday?" and they say, "December 23rd," go, "Oh, I am so sorry..." and buy them some chocolate. Immediately.

Together, we can help a few of them not feel so bad.


The Peanut Gallery responds with: 3 comments


My winter looks like this:
Dad's birthday present
Dad's hannukkah present*
One of my best friend's birthday present**
Christmas presents for everyone ***
Parent's wedding anniversary present
Mom's birthday present.

THEN the holidays are finally, financially over.

*family compromise -- only "the kids" (that's me and my brother) get presents in general, and we only give them to Dad, since he's been Jewish longest.
** - normally a show. In fact, for the longest time I forgot he was a 12/21 birthday, and wondered why he always eagerly accepted my invitations to Rudolph the Red Hosed Reindeer or whatever
*** - mom, dad, brother, aunt, significant other, boss's dog, department secretary - they get "gifts". everyone else gets baked goods.

Posted by Webpixie @ 12/11/2003 05:09 PM EST


> While by no means excusing the practice, I wonder if the combo gift
> was to avoid sibling jealousy.

Good question. In Christine's case, I doubt it because even though she has sisters, they were all grown and out of the house by the time she was 9. But her mother was disabled, and they lived alone, so the combo gift was done out of financial neccessity most of the time (but still does not forgive forgetting it).

The "combo gift" I hear from all over, even in other people's blogs, who are very much adults. My friend Jennifer W. was born on Valentine's day, and for years, boyfriends did the "combo gift" to her as well. On one hand, I can kind of see, yeah, during the holidays you have spent a lot of money, but in most cases, it just seemed so cheap. I didn't have siblings, so I don't know if I had a brother or sister if I'd be bent out of shape of them getting two gifts, because it makes perfect logical sense. But I also know "logical" does not have anything to do with emotions, so you might be right.

I just want people to be happy, you know? That's real sweet of you to get two presents for your mom. Moms get forgotten so much, and it's usually them that busts their ass to make sure the holidays are done right and stay sane.

Posted by Punkie @ 12/11/2003 04:01 PM EST


Since my mom was born on Dec. 30th, I know the pain. Ever since I can remember, we've made sure to get her a present and a nice dinner for her B-Day.

That, and the fact that my birthday is September 11th has given me a new perspective on the subject of having a overwhelmingly significant date for a birthday. "Come to My Party, or the Terrorists Will Have Already Won!"

While by no means excusing the practice, I wonder if the combo gift was to avoid sibling jealousy. Kids at a certain age can be like the IRS agent of one's worst nightmares if they think one kid is getting more attention/presents/less chores than themselves. They can't really help it at that age, they're kids, and in their POV, they need to make sure that their supply of love/food/shelter isn't getting cut off.

Posted by Malle Babbe @ 12/11/2003 11:48 AM EST

Powered By Greymatter


[ Home ] [ What's New ] [ About Me ] [ My Writings ] [ Web Links ] [ Post Office ]